Cars for sale in New Carlisle, Ohio
1,978 cars found
Save this search
Modify Your Search
Location
Price
Hide cars with no price
Under $5,000 (7)
Under $10,000 (37)
Under $15,000 (116)
Under $20,000 (240)
Under $25,000 (409)
Under $30,000 (603)
Under $35,000 (745)
Under $45,000 (937)
Under $55,000 (1,031)
Under $70,000 (1,094)
Under $90,000 (1,114)
Unknown (852)
see all
see less
Mileage
0 miles (544)
Under 10,000 (579)
Under 20,000 (657)
Under 30,000 (756)
Under 40,000 (875)
Under 50,000 (974)
Under 60,000 (1,034)
Under 70,000 (1,110)
Under 80,000 (1,158)
Under 90,000 (1,205)
Under 100,000 (1,257)
Over 100,000 (150)
Unknown (27)
see all
see less
Year
2025 (661)
2024 (446)
2023 (145)
2022 (157)
2021 (149)
2020 (75)
2019 (61)
2018 (58)
2017 (54)
2016 (37)
2015 (28)
2014 (22)
2013 (30)
2012 (12)
2011 (14)
2010 (9)
2009 (3)
2008 (3)
2007 (4)
2006 (3)
2005 (1)
2004 (3)
2003 (1)
2002 (1)
1982 (1)
see all
see less
Exterior Color
?
Unknown
(834)
see all
see less
Make
see all
see less
Bodystyle
Unknown (2)
see all
see less
Transmission
Automatic (1,369)
CVT (244)
Manual (28)
Unknown (337)
Drivetrain
4WD (4X4) (758)
FWD (602)
AWD (492)
RWD (78)
4X2 (28)
Fuel Type
Gasoline (1,627)
Flex Fuel (122)
Gas/Electric Hybrid (59)
Plug-in Hybrid (51)
Diesel (40)
Bio Diesel (31)
Electric (28)
see all
see less
Interior Color
Black
(790)
Gray
(192)
Beige
(43)
Red
(23)
Brown
(19)
Tan
(19)
Maroon
(2)
Blue
(1)
Green
(1)
Orange
(1)
Silver
(1)
White
(1)
?
Unknown
(968)
see all
see less
C.A.R.Score Overall Grade
0 or higher (1)
1 or higher (1)
2 or higher (1)
3 or higher (1)
4 or higher (1)
C.A.R.Score Interior Grade
0 or higher (1)
1 or higher (1)
2 or higher (1)
3 or higher (1)
4 or higher (1)
C.A.R.Score Exterior Grade
0 or higher (1)
1 or higher (1)
2 or higher (1)
3 or higher (1)
Only show fuel efficient
Only show cars with photos
Only show cars with C.A.R.Score
Featured Listings
Save this car
$15,230 ($287/mo est.)
Mileage: 148,706
1 photo
Mileage:
148,706
Exterior Color:
Red
Drivetrain:
AWD
Transmission:
Automatic
MPG (city/hwy):
18/24
$15,230 ($287/mo est.)
Vandalia, OH
(557 miles from )
(557 miles from )
Save this car
Save this car
$25,016 ($472/mo est.)
Mileage: 61,881
1 photo
Mileage:
61,881
Exterior Color:
Gray
Interior Color:
Black
Drivetrain:
RWD
Transmission:
Manual
$25,016 ($472/mo est.)
Vandalia, OH
(557 miles from )
(557 miles from )
Save this car
Save this car
$25,576 ($483/mo est.)
Mileage: 21,112
1 photo
Mileage:
21,112
Exterior Color:
Red
Interior Color:
Black
Drivetrain:
FWD
Transmission:
Automatic
$25,576 ($483/mo est.)
Vandalia, OH
(557 miles from )
(557 miles from )
Save this car
Standard Listings
Save this car
$36,290 ($685/mo est.)
Mileage: 47,325
30 photos
Mileage:
47,325
Exterior Color:
White
Drivetrain:
RWD
Transmission:
A
Engine:
3.5L Flex Fuel V6 275hp 262ft. lbs.
$36,290 ($685/mo est.)
Vandalia, OH
(557 miles from )
(557 miles from )
Save this car
$59,375 ($1,120/mo est.)
Mileage: 0
32 photos
Mileage:
0
Exterior Color:
Gun Metallic
Drivetrain:
4WD (4X4)
Transmission:
A
Engine:
5.6L V8 400hp 413ft. lbs.
$59,375 ($1,120/mo est.)
Vandalia, OH
(557 miles from )
(557 miles from )
Save this car
$7,977 ($151/mo est.)
Mileage: 131,590
30 photos
Mileage:
131,590
Exterior Color:
Shadow Black
Interior Color:
Black
Drivetrain:
FWD
Transmission:
A
$7,977 ($151/mo est.)
Vandalia, OH
(557 miles from )
(557 miles from )
Save this car
$31,995 ($604/mo est.)
Mileage: 88
37 photos
Mileage:
88
Exterior Color:
Black
Drivetrain:
AWD
Transmission:
A
MPG (city/hwy):
21/28
$31,995 ($604/mo est.)
Vandalia, OH
(557 miles from )
(557 miles from )
Save this car
$32,745 ($618/mo est.)
Mileage: 43,002
30 photos
Mileage:
43,002
Exterior Color:
Blue
Drivetrain:
4WD (4X4)
Transmission:
A
MPG (city/hwy):
12/15
$32,745 ($618/mo est.)
Vandalia, OH
(557 miles from )
(557 miles from )
Save this car
Contact for Price
Mileage: 87,151
1 photo
Mileage:
87,151
Exterior Color:
Taupe Gray Metallic
Interior Color:
Titanium
Drivetrain:
FWD
Transmission:
A
Contact for Price
Vandalia, OH
(557 miles from )
(557 miles from )
Save this car
$21,645 ($408/mo est.)
Mileage: 48,144
31 photos
Mileage:
48,144
Exterior Color:
Pyrite Silver Metallic
Interior Color:
Black
Drivetrain:
AWD
Transmission:
A
$21,645 ($408/mo est.)
Vandalia, OH
(557 miles from )
(557 miles from )
Save this car
$29,785 ($562/mo est.)
Mileage: 40,455
30 photos
Mileage:
40,455
Exterior Color:
Oxford White
Drivetrain:
AWD
Transmission:
A
MPG (city/hwy):
20/27
$29,785 ($562/mo est.)
Vandalia, OH
(557 miles from )
(557 miles from )
Save this car
$20,265 ($382/mo est.)
Mileage: 32,844
31 photos
Mileage:
32,844
Exterior Color:
Black Cherry
Interior Color:
Gray
Drivetrain:
FWD
Transmission:
A
$20,265 ($382/mo est.)
Vandalia, OH
(557 miles from )
(557 miles from )
Save this car
$31,995 ($604/mo est.)
Mileage: 24,299
22 photos
Mileage:
24,299
Exterior Color:
Red
Interior Color:
Ebony
Drivetrain:
4WD (4X4)
Transmission:
A
$31,995 ($604/mo est.)
Vandalia, OH
(557 miles from )
(557 miles from )
Save this car
$35,095 ($662/mo est.)
Mileage: 17,344
31 photos
Mileage:
17,344
Exterior Color:
Ebony Black
Drivetrain:
AWD
Transmission:
A
MPG (city/hwy):
22/27
$35,095 ($662/mo est.)
Vandalia, OH
(557 miles from )
(557 miles from )
Save this car
$25,995 ($491/mo est.)
Mileage: 57,308
26 photos
Mileage:
57,308
Exterior Color:
Ceramic Gray Clearcoat
Drivetrain:
FWD
Transmission:
A
MPG (city/hwy):
19/28
$25,995 ($491/mo est.)
Vandalia, OH
(557 miles from )
(557 miles from )
Save this car
$24,075 ($454/mo est.)
Mileage: 21,513
31 photos
Mileage:
21,513
Exterior Color:
Summit White
Interior Color:
Jet Black
Drivetrain:
FWD
Transmission:
A
$24,075 ($454/mo est.)
Vandalia, OH
(557 miles from )
(557 miles from )
Save this car
$31,790 ($600/mo est.)
Mileage: 50,097
31 photos
Mileage:
50,097
Exterior Color:
Rich Copper
Drivetrain:
AWD
Transmission:
A
MPG (city/hwy):
20/27
$31,790 ($600/mo est.)
Vandalia, OH
(557 miles from )
(557 miles from )
Save this car
$22,640 ($427/mo est.)
Mileage: 49,770
30 photos
Mileage:
49,770
Exterior Color:
Gun Metallic
Interior Color:
Graphite
Drivetrain:
AWD
Transmission:
CVT
$22,640 ($427/mo est.)
Vandalia, OH
(557 miles from )
(557 miles from )
Save this car
$31,985 ($604/mo est.)
Mileage: 19,812
30 photos
Mileage:
19,812
Exterior Color:
Cactus Green / Gray
Drivetrain:
4WD (4X4)
Transmission:
A
MPG (city/hwy):
20/24
$31,985 ($604/mo est.)
Vandalia, OH
(557 miles from )
(557 miles from )
Save this car
$17,645 ($333/mo est.)
Mileage: 82,398
30 photos
Mileage:
82,398
Exterior Color:
Snowflake White Pearl Mica
Interior Color:
White
Drivetrain:
FWD
Transmission:
A
$17,645 ($333/mo est.)
Vandalia, OH
(557 miles from )
(557 miles from )
Save this car
$29,940 ($565/mo est.)
Mileage: 56,636
31 photos
Mileage:
56,636
Exterior Color:
White
Interior Color:
Charcoal
Drivetrain:
AWD
Transmission:
A
$29,940 ($565/mo est.)
Vandalia, OH
(557 miles from )
(557 miles from )
Save this car
$34,995 ($660/mo est.)
Mileage: 32,546
32 photos
Mileage:
32,546
Exterior Color:
Pristine White
Interior Color:
Sandstone
Drivetrain:
FWD
Transmission:
A
$34,995 ($660/mo est.)
Vandalia, OH
(557 miles from )
(557 miles from )
Save this car
$25,495 ($481/mo est.)
Mileage: 19,306
32 photos
Mileage:
19,306
Exterior Color:
Red
Interior Color:
Medium Dark Slate
Drivetrain:
AWD
Transmission:
A
$25,495 ($481/mo est.)
Vandalia, OH
(557 miles from )
(557 miles from )
Save this car
$24,860 ($469/mo est.)
Mileage: 36,596
30 photos
Mileage:
36,596
Exterior Color:
Black
Interior Color:
Charcoal
Drivetrain:
AWD
Transmission:
CVT
$24,860 ($469/mo est.)
Vandalia, OH
(557 miles from )
(557 miles from )
Save this car
$24,015 ($453/mo est.)
Mileage: 65,138
31 photos
Mileage:
65,138
Exterior Color:
Black
Interior Color:
Charcoal
Drivetrain:
AWD
Transmission:
CVT
$24,015 ($453/mo est.)
Vandalia, OH
(557 miles from )
(557 miles from )
This image is a stock photo and is not an exact representation of any vehicle offered for sale. Advertised vehicles of this model may have styling, trim levels, colors and optional equipment that differ from the stock photo.
Close
Filter Results
Updating Results